If you’ve been investing for a reasonable amount of time sure you’ve realised how important it is to analyse the working capital management of the company. If like me you are always looking for shortcuts to evaluate companies this article may be especially useful to you.
It is a shortcut that I’ve come across that helps you evaluate the working capital investment of a company quickly and very effectively I’m sure you are aware of the normal ratios used to evaluate working capital.
Here they are:
- The current ratio (current assets / current liabilities) as a general rule a value greater than 1,5 is good
- The quick ratio also called the acid test ratio ((current assets – inventory) / current liabilities) a value greater than 1 is good
- Days inventory on hand ((inventory / cost of goods sold) * 365) Compare this number to competitors to see if it is good or bad. Be careful if it keeps deteriorating.
- Days of accounts receivable ((accounts receivable / sales) * 365) Again, compare this number to competitors to see if it is good or bad and be careful if it keeps deteriorating
To this I would like to add this very innovative way of evaluating working capital that you may not have heard of. It is a ratio that I discovered when reading old articles from the Motley Fool, more specifically an article written in 1999 by a friend and hedge fund manager Zeke Ashton.
You can find the whole article here The Early Warning Flow In spite of the article being written in 1999, just like all good advice, it is as relevant today as it was then. Before I tell you how to calculate the ratio let me start at the end and explain what the ratio tells you.
The lower it is the better.
A low flow ratio tells you if a company has an asset light business model or if it manages its working capital well.
A low ration means the company either has a low amount of current assets or it is able to finance current assets entirely with low or no cost current liabilities (like accounts receivable).
A high flow ratio means that the company has to invest a substantial amount of money in working capital assets or that the company is really bad at managing its working capital.
Bad working capital management would be having too much inventory or collecting accounts receivable very slowly.
A ratio of less than 1,5 is really good.
Should the ratio go over three, it’s a warning sign for you to find out why it is so high or to be very careful before investing in the company.
Now on to how it is calculated…
Have you signed up for my free weekly newsletter “Investing that makes sense” yet?
Sign up now and receive articles like this in your inbox weekly.
And if you sign up now you will also receive a 10 page free bonus report – Enhanced Checklist for Value Investors – with over 30 proven checklist items to improve your investment returns.
The ratio is calculated as follows:
Flow (Current Assets – (Cash + Short-term Investments))
Ratio = ————————————————————————
(Current Liabilities – Short-term Debt)
The top part of the ratio or the numerator. The ratio isolates the bad current assets by subtracting the good current assets which are cash and short-term investments.
Bad current assets are mainly accounts receivable and inventory. Accounts receivable are sales for which the company hasn’t received payment yet. The longer it takes to collect accounts receivable the more likely it becomes that they may not be collected.
Inventory is goods purchased waiting to be sold, and like accounts receivable, the longer goods take to be sold the less valuable they become.
They may thus become outdated or obsolete.
The bottom part of the ratio or the denominator Here you calculate the good current liabilities.
Good current liabilities are those that don’t cost the company anything.
Current liabilities contain short term liabilities a company has to pay. These consist mainly of accounts payable, which are services and goods the company has received but hasn’t paid for and short term debt.
Because debt costs interest it is deducted from total current liabilities.
So what the Flow Ratio does is it shows the ratio of bad current assets to good current liabilities.
It shows you to what extent a company is able to finance its bad current assets with current liabilities that do not cost any interest.
Thus the lower the Flow Ratio, the better the company is at maximizing the value of its cash flow.
But that is not all
As mentioned a low Flow Ratio also tells you that the company has an asset light business model and/or excellent working capital management.
Keep in mind a rising Flow Ratio shows a deterioration of these qualities.
Your analysing analyst